This paper frames a normative theory of stewardship engagement by large institutional investors and asset managers in terms of their theory of investment management – “Modern Portfolio Theory” – which describes investors as attentive to both systematic risk as well as expected returns.
Because investors want to maximize risk-adjusted returns, it will serve their interests for asset managers to support and sometimes advance shareholder initiatives that will reduce systematic risk. “Systematic Stewardship” provides an approach to “ESG” matters that serves both investor welfare and social welfare and fits the business model of large diversified funds, especially index funds. The analysis also shows why it is generally unwise for such funds to pursue stewardship that consists of firm-specific performance-focused engagement: Gains (if any) will be substantially “idiosyncratic,” precisely the kind of risks that diversification minimizes. Instead asset managers should seek to mitigate systematic risk, which most notably would include climate change risk, financial stability risk, and social stability risk.
This portfolio approach follows the already established pattern of asset managers’ pursuit of corporate governance measures that may increase returns across the portfolio if even not maximizing for particular firms. Systematic Stewardship does not raise the concerns of the “common ownership” critique, because the channel by which systematic risk reduction improves risk-adjusted portfolio returns is to avoid harm across the entire economy that would damage the interests of employees and consumers as well as shareholders.
The paper for this seminar can be found here.
This seminar will take place online. Please register online if you would like to join this seminar. Once you have registered, you will receive an email from Eventbrite and you can access the Zoom link for the seminar by clicking “view the event” in the email.
About the Speaker
Jeffrey N. Gordon is Richard Paul Richman Professor of Law at Columbia, where he is co-director of the Millstein Center for Global Markets and Corporate Ownership and co-director of the Richman Center for Business, Law and Public Policy. He is also a Visiting Professor in the Law Faculty of the University of Oxford and a Fellow of the European Corporate Governance Institute. Recent projects include Principles of Financial Regulation (with co-authors) and The Oxford Handbook of Corporate Law and Governance (co-editor with Georg Ringe), and an effort, with Ronald Gilson, to reformulate an alternative model for the public company board, Board 3.0.
About the ACLE
The Amsterdam Center for Law and Economics (ACLE) is a joint initiative of the Faculty of Economics and Business and the Faculty of Law at the University of Amsterdam. The objective of the ACLE is to promote high-quality interdisciplinary research at the intersection between law and economics.