Why Regression Discontinuity Designs Have Often Underestimated the Incumbency Advantage Effect: Why Should Economists Be Interested in Theory?
-
Series
-
Speaker
-
FieldOrganizations and Markets
-
LocationErasmus University Rotterdam, Campus Woudestein, Langeveld 4.18
Rotterdam -
Date and time
April 07, 2026
13:00 - 14:15
Abstract
The incumbency advantage, the electoral benefit from holding office, is widely estimated using regression discontinuity designs (RDDs) in close elections. Existing estimates typically pool first-term and multiple-term incumbents. We show that this pooling attenuates RDD estimates when candidate characteristics contain persistent shocks, such as quality: a multiple-term incumbent who barely wins has already revealed low quality, fully absorbing the incumbency premium. Using U.S. House (1942-2008) and Portuguese municipal elections (1976-2025), estimates for one-term incumbents are 13.5 and 13.8 percentage points versus 7.8 and 2.8 pp for multiple-term incumbents. Standard pooled RDD estimates understate the causal incumbency advantage from first-time officeholding by 20-30 percent.